Are Biopics Good Cinema? A Guide to Writing and Directing Biopics

“Action!”

Behind every extraordinary life is an extraordinary story – and no place understands this better than Hollywood. Since the earliest days of cinema, biopics have been a beloved genre, allowing filmmakers to explore the lives of remarkable individuals and share their captivating stories with audiences worldwide.

But what makes biopics so enduring? What separates a great biopic from a formulaic retelling of someone’s life? And how can writers and directors ensure their biopic captures the essence of its subject while still delivering a compelling cinematic experience?

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the art of writing and directing biopics, exploring the challenges and triumphs of bringing real-life stories to the big screen. From crafting compelling narratives to casting the perfect leads and capturing the spirit of an era, we’ll uncover the secrets behind some of the most celebrated biopics in film history.

So, join us on this journey as we explore the world of biopics, and discover why these films continue to captivate audiences and cement their place in the annals of great cinema.

Chapter 1: Writing a Captivating Biopic

The Art of Research

Unsurprisingly, writing a compelling biopic requires an immense amount of research. But it’s not just about amassing facts and figures – it’s about understanding what makes your subject truly fascinating and worthy of a cinematic adaptation.

As Andrei Tarkovsky, the visionary director behind the biopic “Andrei Rublev,” explains, the key lies in finding the universal themes and elements within a person’s story that audiences can grasp onto and relate to. It’s about elevating the personal to the profound, and crafting a narrative that transcends mere biography and speaks to the shared human experience.

Finding the Right Focus

One of the most challenging aspects of writing a biopic is deciding where to begin and where to end. After all, a movie can only cover so much of a person’s life, and attempting to cram an entire existence into a two-hour runtime often results in a disjointed, surface-level exploration.

As Danny Boyle, the director of “127 Hours,” suggests, the most effective biopics don’t try to stretch from cradle to grave. Instead, they hone in on a specific, intense experience or event that serves as a window into the subject’s life and character.

Jane Campion, the writer-director of “Bright Star,” echoes this sentiment. When crafting her biopic about the poet John Keats, she chose to focus on his love story with Fanny Brawne, recognizing that this intimate chapter held the emotional core of his life and work.

Crafting Complex Characters

Once you’ve identified the focus of your biopic, it’s time to decide how your subject will function within the narrative. Aaron Sorkin, the mastermind behind “The Social Network,” chose to portray Mark Zuckerberg as an antihero – a flawed, multidimensional character who, despite his questionable actions, still manages to elicit empathy and understanding from the audience.

For larger-than-life figures, grounding them as relatable human beings is essential. Sophia Coppola, in her biopic “Marie Antoinette,” was struck by how young and vulnerable the infamous queen was, and sought to portray her as a real person with both sympathetic qualities and flaws.

Hayao Miyazaki took a similar approach in “The Wind Rises,” aiming to understand his protagonist within the context of their time and circumstances, rather than judging them through a modern lens.

Chapter 2: Casting the Perfect Leads

Casting a biopic is a delicate dance. Audiences often have preconceived notions about what a public figure looked and behaved like, so striking the right balance between physical resemblance and capturing the essence of the character is crucial.

When casting the role of Nixon in his eponymous biopic, Oliver Stone chose Anthony Hopkins precisely because he could transcend mere impersonation and imbue the character with depth and nuance. As Stone explains, Hopkins allowed audiences to look beyond Nixon’s inscrutable exterior and glimpse the complexity of the man beneath.

In Christopher Nolan’s “Oppenheimer,” the director opted for a star-studded ensemble cast, leveraging the recognizability of actors like Cillian Murphy and Emily Blunt to immediately establish the historical figures they portrayed and lend a sense of gravitas to the proceedings.

David Fincher took a similar approach with “The Social Network,” casting pop icon Justin Timberlake as Sean Parker to capture the charismatic energy and magnetism of the infamous entrepreneur.

Beyond Physical Resemblance

While physical resemblance is often a consideration, some directors prioritize an actor’s ability to channel the interiority of a character over surface-level appearances. Michael Mann’s casting of Russell Crowe in “The Insider,” despite Crowe being nearly two decades younger than the real-life whistleblower he portrayed, is a prime example of this philosophy.

In one pivotal scene, Mann recognized Crowe’s ability to convey the profound sense of devastation and inner turmoil experienced by his character – a quality that transcended age or nationality.

Todd Haynes took this concept even further in his unconventional biopic “I’m Not There,” casting multiple actors, including Cate Blanchett, to embody different facets of Bob Dylan’s multifaceted persona and ever-evolving artistic identity.

Immersive Research

For many actors, inhabiting the role of a real-life figure involves extensive research and preparation. Some, like Jack Black in “Bernie,” choose to meet and interact with the person they’re portraying, absorbing their mannerisms and idiosyncrasies firsthand.

In other cases, actors rely on secondary sources and the insights of those closest to their subjects. Annette Bening, in her portrayal of long-distance swimmer Diana Nyad in the film “Nyad,” spent months not only studying Nyad herself but also her close friend Bonnie Stoll, seeking to understand the depth of their friendship and the emotional core that drove Nyad’s extraordinary achievements.

Chapter 3: Capturing the Essence on Screen

Striking the Right Tone

Just as writing a biopic requires a delicate balance between fact and dramatization, so too does filming one. Some directors lean more heavily into artistic license, while others strive for a more faithful, documentary-like approach.

Ava DuVernay, in her powerful biopic “Selma,” embraces her role as an artist exploring history, using her film as a canvas to pose questions, explore ideas, and offer her unique perspective on the events depicted.

On the other end of the spectrum, Steven Spielberg opted for a gritty, documentarian aesthetic in “Schindler’s List,” aiming to create a personal, intimate experience for audiences rather than the sweeping grandeur of a traditional epic.

Visual Storytelling

Effective biopics often employ stylistic elements and visual techniques to capture the essence of their subjects and convey their interior lives. Marielle Heller’s “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood,” for instance, employs a surrealist aesthetic that evokes the whimsical yet emotionally resonant world of “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood.”

In “Shirley,” Josephine Decker uses a layered approach to reality, blurring the lines between the protagonist’s internal and external worlds, and offering glimpses into the imaginative process of a writer at work.

For Paul Schrader’s biopic of the author and playwright Yukio Mishima, the diverse theatrical styles employed mirror the multifaceted nature of Mishima’s life and work, creating a unique visual language to explore his complex legacy.

Authenticity Through Research

Extensive visual research is often a crucial component of capturing the authentic essence of a biopic’s setting and time period. Steve McQueen’s “12 Years a Slave” is a powerful example of how immersing oneself in the real locations and environments can transform a film, infusing it with a tangible sense of reality that transcends the written word.

In “The Grandmaster,” Wong Kar-Wai meticulously studied the mechanics and movements of various Kung Fu masters, ensuring that the film’s fight sequences accurately captured the art form’s intricacies and nuances.

And for “Tick, Tick… Boom,” Lin-Manuel Miranda and his team pored over video footage and personal artifacts from Jonathan Larson’s life, ensuring that even the smallest details – like the bend in a bookshelf – accurately reflected the late composer’s lived experiences.

Conclusion

As we’ve seen, biopics are a unique and challenging genre, requiring a delicate balance of research, artistic vision, and a deep understanding of what makes a life story truly cinematic. From crafting compelling narratives and complex characters to casting the perfect leads and capturing the authentic essence of a time and place, the art of writing and directing biopics demands a multifaceted approach.

Yet when executed skillfully, biopics have the power to transport audiences, offering a window into the lives of extraordinary individuals and illuminating the universal truths that bind us all. They remind us that behind every remarkable life is a story waiting to be told – a story of triumphs and struggles, of passion and perseverance, of the human spirit’s enduring capacity for greatness.